Showing posts with label Ethanol. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Ethanol. Show all posts

Friday, March 12, 2010

EPA Finalizes Changes to Renewable Fuel Standard Program

Milbank's Renewable Fuel Standard Client Update sheds light on the outlook for biofuels.

Special thanks to Milbank, Tweed, Hadley & McCloy LLP

Introduction

The Environmental Protection Agency (“EPA”) has finalized regulations that update the Renewable Fuel Standard (“RFS”) Program, pursuant to the Energy Independence and Security Act of 2007 (“EISA,” Pub. L. No. 110-140).1 The initial RFS Program (“RFS1”), established by the Energy Policy Act of 2005 (Pub. L. No. 109-58), required a minimum volume of renewable fuel to be blended into gasoline each year.2 The new program (“RFS2”) now applies to all transportation fuel, increases the volume standard and creates new fuel categories and eligibility requirements, including mandatory greenhouse gas (“GHG”) reduction thresholds for select fuels.3


RFS2 expands on the purposes originally set forth by RFS1. By mandating minimum volumes of renewable fuel in the U.S. fuel supply, it is expected that greenhouse gas emissions will decrease, greater independence from imported petroleum will be achieved, and the nation’s renewable fuels sector will grow considerably.4 EPA has projected that by 2022, when the required volume of renewable fuels increases to 36 billion gallons (“bg”), there will be new and expanded markets for agricultural products, like corn and soybeans, and cellulosic feedstock, as well as markets for advanced biofuels and conversion technologies.5

To further encourage growth in the biofuel sector, the U.S. Department of Agriculture is considering increasing funding for companies that want to convert biomass to bio-energy and bio-based products.6 The EPA is also reviewing a Clean Air Act waiver request that, if approved, would permit the ethanol content of gasoline to be increased from10 percent to 15 percent.7 This would allow the market to better absorb the increase in biofuels. Though EPA does not expect to issue a decision until mid-2010, the Agency has indicated the “need” to approve such an increase.8


This all coincides with the expansion and promotion of renewables. As mentioned earlier, the
RFS2 program now applies to all transportation fuel. This includes gasoline and diesel for use in motor vehicles, motor vehicle engines, nonroad vehicles and nonroad engines.9 It also includes marine diesel, heating and jet fuel.10 This means that refiners, except for small refiners that fall into the statutory exclusion, and importers who produce or import such gasoline or diesel fuel within the 48 contiguous states or Hawaii have to comply with the standards set out in RFS2.11 In areas where a U.S. territory opts in, the standards also apply.12 The new regulations set out in this recent final ruling will apply starting on or after July 1, 2010. However, with regards to the volume standards each obligated party must meet, the compliance period runs from January 1, 2010 to December 31, 2010.13



Click here for the full article from the Milbank website.

The following chart details the RFS schedule BEFORE the EPA updates to the program.






Tuesday, January 5, 2010

Top Energy Stories of 2009

Top Energy Stories of 2009: Volatility, Exxon's Nat Gas Bet and Ethanol Bankruptcies (and Bargains)


The year is wrapping up literally in a few hours here in the U.S. So, why not look back at the biggest oil and gas — OK, and ethanol — stories of 2009. In a year, where a barrel of crude touched a low of $32.70 in January and then subsequently rose to $82 in October before backing off slightly. Today, crude oil for February delivery is just below $80.
In short, it’s been a volatile year. Throw in a recession — and the weak demand for fuel that comes with it — and you get a year filled with bankruptcies, mergers and a great shifting of resources. So, here are some of the biggest energy stories of 2009, not in any particular order. Feel free to add ones you think I missed.

ExxonMobil buys XTO Energy: We waited all year for Exxon to do something with its cash. And bam! It finally happens. Exxon announced in December it would acquire independent oil and gas producer XTO Energy in a $31 billion all-stock purchase, the company’s biggest purchase in more than a decade. Exxon also agreed assume $10 billion in debt as part of the deal.
Any acquisition this big that involves Exxon is sure to make any top stories list. But there’s another reason: unconventional natural gas. XTO is a major player in unconventional gas and Exxon’s acquisition is one giant bet that nat gas will be the world’s go-to power source.

China’s energy appetite: The country and its insatiable thirst for energy resources came up in dozens of BNET Energy posts in 2009 whether it was its continued purchase of gas from sources like Chevron’s Gorgon LNG project, its loans-for-fuel deals with countries in South America, its success in the Iraq oil auction or its attempts to snap up Kosmos Energy. And the trend will surely continue into 2010.

Refiner Valero Energy gets into ethanol: We’re not talking small potatoes here. Valero Energy, the largest independent U.S. refiner, bought up last March seven ethanol plants and a development site from bankrupt VeraSun for $477 million — a ridiculous 70 percent discount. The purchase translates into about 780 million gallons of ethanol a year Valero won’t have to buy from outside companies to meet the federal Renewable Fuels Standard.

And it’s actually turned out to be a moneymaker. The company earned $22 million on operating income in the second quarter from its ethanol segment. That number more than doubled in the third quarter, which is good news for any refining business right now. Valero is its eyes on more ethanol plants. The company announced it would buy Renew Energy’s 110 million gallon per year plant for $72 million. That deal could be scuttled by a motion filed with the U.S. Bankruptcy Court by ALL Fuels & Energy out of Iowa, which claims it was the highest bidder.

Valero wasn’t the only company to take advantage of these bargain basement ethanol prices. Philadelphia-based oil refiner Sunoco jumped into the ethanol-producing business in May with its $8.5 million bid for a Northeast Biofuels plant, which originally cost $200 million to build back in 2006. Ethanol producer Green Plains Renewable Energy also got into the mix. The company bought two plants in Nebraska for $123.5 million from AgStar Financial Services, a lending group that purchased that from VeraSun.

Iraq’s Oil Auctions: Iraq opened its door just a smidgen to foreign firms this year, giving oil companies access to the country’s resources for the first time in nearly four decades. The country held two auctions, which allowed international and national oil companies to bid on contracts to produce oil.

The first auction in July received poor reviews after only one contract was secured by BP and its consortium partner China National Petroleum Co. BP was the only firm willing to lower its per barrel fee to $2, the maximum amount Iraq’s oil ministry said it would pay. The auction in December produced two contracts. Once again, China — as part of a consortium with minority partner Total – snapped up one of the development contracts. Royal Dutch Shell and Petronas of Malaysia were awarded right to develop the Majnoon oil, one of the world’s largest remaining untapped oil fields.
Chevron, partners give final OK to Gorgon LNG plant: Chevron and its partners ExxonMobil and Royal Dutch Shell gave the thumbs up to its $37 billion Gorgon liquefied natural gas venture. The final investment decision to build the massive facility located in Western Australia was made only after Australia’s government assumed any long-term liability for potential damages incurred from carbon storage, a key feature of the project.

Climate legislation: There isn’t a bill, yet. But the House passed its version in June and the Senate has made a few attempts including the recent triapartisan compromise bill from Sens. John Kerry, D-Mass., Lindsey Graham, R-S.C., and Joseph Lieberman, I-Conn. Lobby efforts from environmental groups as well as oil, gas and coal have ramped up to new heights. And even the U.S. Chamber of Commerce has gotten into the act, with its call for a Scopes-like Monkey Trial on global warming and the exodus of companies from the business organization that followed.
EPA’s endangerment finding: The Environmental Protection Agency deemed greenhouse gas emissions a danger to human health and welfare, a finding that has vast implications for the regulation of carbon dioxide and the businesses that emit it. If approved by the Office of Management and Budget, the EPA will likely issue rules to regulate greenhouse gas emissions under the authority of the Clean Air Act. This means the EPA — not Congress — would be writing the rules for emitters of greenhouse gases. And that does not make the oil and gas industry happy.

Monday, June 8, 2009

Ethanol Industry Update - Seeking Alpha


by MARIE DAGHLIAN
A combination of lower oil prices and challenging financial markets continues to spell disaster for U.S. ethanol companies, with another 10 providers of this first-generation biofuel going belly up in the first five months of 2009. Among the latest was Pacific Ethanol (PEIX), which saw its shares swoon 44 percent to 32 cents on May 19 when five of its six ethanol-producing units filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection. The company had gone public in 2005 with shares debuting at $12.95.
Since the bankruptcy filing, Pacific Ethanol’s share price has been inching up, trading at 46 cents a share on June 4. But like many of its competitors, the Sacramento, California-based company, which reported sales of $700 million in 2008, has been struggling with a shortage of cash, high corn prices, and lower ethanol prices. At the end of October 2008, VeraSun had one of the first companies to go bust, leading to a succession of firms like Pacific Ethanol that have had trouble staying afloat.
Despite government subsidies and clean-fuel mandates, first-generation corn ethanol companies have had a bumpy ride. The Energy Independence and Security Act of 2007 paved the way for capital projects to ramp up ethanol production to meet the new mandate. But the initial euphoria evaporated when record-high spikes in energy and corn prices rocked the market.
The ethanol industry’s expansion had been an economic driver in 2008, according to industry research. A study commissioned by the Renewable Fuels Association said the industry spent $22 billion on materials and labor and another $2.5 billion on grain transportation services. The investment increased production capacity 34 percent to reach 12.5 billion gallons of ethanol a year, well above the federally mandated requirement of 10.6 billion gallons in the nation’s gasoline supply in 2009. The study also found the ethanol industry generated $21 billion in federal, state, and local tax revenue.
However, market volatility ended up spelling disaster for companies that had borrowed heavily to increase production capacity. Surging energy and feedstock prices, which reached their peak in June 2008, increased both the demand for ethanol and the cost of production. But as the price of oil plummeted, so did the demand for ethanol and the price it could command. Increased production capacity also depressed ethanol prices. At the same time, the economy took a nosedive, quickly landing many ethanol players in trouble. As capital dried up, plants were idled, production projects stalled, and many producers became unable to make payments on their huge debt loads. Production in 2008 ended up falling slightly short of the 9-billion gallon mandate.
Among some of this year’s other casualties, Aventine Renewable Energy Holdings [AVRNQ.PK] was de-listed from the New York Stock Exchange in March and filed a voluntary Chapter 11 petition two weeks later in April, saying it had had nearly $800 million of assets and nearly $491 million of debt at the end of 2008. Once a high flyer, the company's stock debuted at $39.27 in July of 2006. It has been trading around 15 cents a share in recent weeks.
“Ethanol demand has also been negatively affected by refiners and blenders using excess renewable identification numbers (RINs) to help meet their renewable fuels standard obligations instead of purchasing actual gallons of ethanol,” Avertine said in the April 8 statement announcing its Chapter 11 bankruptcy filing. The company also blamed operating margins and high gasoline prices as having negatively affected the ethanol industry. As part of Aventine’s bankruptcy filing, the company and certain holders of its 10 percent senior unsecured notes agreed to a first priority secured debtor-in-possession term loan totaling $30 million so the company could continue operating. However, at the end of May, Aventine began publicly soliciting potential investor interest in order to recapitalize or sell its business, setting a deadline of June 17 the for submissions.
Then there is Cambridge, Massachusetts cellulosic ethanol and enzyme developer Verenium (VRNM), an advanced biofuel company that has attracted a lot of investment, including an ongoing partnership with oil giant BP. The company opened a demonstration-scale cellulosic production facility in Jennings, Louisiana in May 2008 and has plans to build a 36-million gallon commercial facility in Florida in collaboration with BP.
In March, Verenium received a going concern qualification as part of its 10-K form filing with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission as result of doubt on behalf of the auditor that the company can continue to move forward under its heavy debt load and may ultimately need to file for bankruptcy. According to the filing, Verenium has had more than $300 million in net losses over the past three years and an accumulated deficit of $622.6 million as of the end of 2008. If the company is not able to raise additional capital, it will also be on the ropes. Although this has not yet happened, it is interesting to note that its shares went public in February 2003 at $103.88 and once traded as high as $149 a share. On June 4th, they were trading at 65 cents a share.
Even though President Barack Obama’s economic stimulus plan is focused on advanced biofuels development, which has not yet been commercialized, he has not forgotten first-generation biofuels producers, offering refinancing options to the industry. At the same time, the Environmental Protection Agency is considering a rule that would raise the amount of ethanol that must be blended into gasoline from 10 percent to 15 percent. Still, many first-generation biofuel producers continue to struggle to survive, trying to catch a break from banks and debt holders who are reluctant to sell valuable property at fire sale prices. At the same time, oil companies, private equity players, and big agribusinesses are hunting for bargains among the troubled companies. Oil refiner Valero (VLO) paid $477 million in March for seven production facilities belonging to bankrupt VeraSun.
Recently, crude oil futures have been moving toward $70 a barrel, and a bullish oil price forecast to $85 a barrel, issued by Goldman Sachs in the past week, has boosted sentiment among energy investors. Observers might assume that should bode well for ethanol producers, but the recent business failures suggest they may be mistaken.
On a brighter note, not all first-generation ethanol producers are suffering. Privately held Poet, the largest U.S. producer of ethanol, has expressed interest in buying new plants, including ones from recently bankrupt companies, which it claims it can turn around, according to Chief executive Jeff Broin who spoke by telephone with attendees at a recent Reuters Global Energy Summit. The company has developed it own technology for distilling ethanol. Poet, which operates 26 plants in seven Midwest states, has managed to remain profitable even during these difficult economic times.

Related Articles

Sunday, March 8, 2009

Renewable Identification Number Credits and the Valero VeraSun Ethanol Deal

RIN Credits, Ethanol Blending and the 800-pound Gorilla


Renewable energy credit prices are on the rise as ethanol blend economics remain poor and the year-end reporting date looms. EPM talks with Clayton McMartin, president of Clean Fuels Clearinghouse, about renewable identification number credits, industry consolidation, and the oil industry’s 800-pound gorilla, Valero Energy Corp., which can no longer be ignored.
By Ron Kotrba

The 800-pound gorilla in the room finally announced itself in early February. For months, speculators have been trying to figure out which ethanol companies will buy out which ethanol plants during this period of crushing economic recession and potential ethanol industry consolidation. Aside from food companies, what other industry made record profits in 2008 and could logically purchase distressed ethanol production facilities? The oil refiners—they who are obligated to blend ethanol into their supplies as mandated under the federal renewable fuels standard (RFS). On Friday, Feb. 6, VeraSun Energy Corp. “took out the trash”—that’s public relations lingo for releasing bad news on a Friday, with the understanding that there will be little coverage of it until at least Monday. The same day, VeraSun issued a press release titled, “VeraSun Energy Obtains ‘Stalking Horse’ Bid From Valero for Five Facilities; Files Motion Seeking Authority to Sell Substantially All Assets by March.”

According to Bill Day, corporate spokesman for Valero Energy Corp., the oil refiner’s 2008 overall production averaged 1.19 million barrels per day of “gasoline and related blend stocks” equaling roughly 18.2 billion gallons a year. The U.S. EPA has declared that this year’s RFS is 11.1 billion gallons, which equals 10.21 percent volume ethanol blend requirement for each of the obligated parties. Assuming Valero’s 2009 gasoline production projections are similar to its 2008 production its share of the 10.21 percent would come to about 1.9 billion gallons of ethanol blending in 2009.

Valero could purchase renewable identification number (RIN) credits to satisfy its obligation. If the oil refiner were to only purchase RINs to satisfy its RFS obligation and blended zero ethanol into its supplies—an unrealistic scenario but interesting to entertain, nevertheless—figuring a historically high RIN credit price of 15 cents per credit, the oil refiner could pay $285 million in RIN credit accumulations to satisfy its obligation for 2009. Instead, Valero proposes to pay $280 million for capital assets that, year after year, will continue to help it internally meet obligations under the RFS. It is also interesting to note that the five VeraSun plants in question have a cumulative nameplate capacity of 560 MMgy, which could satisfy between a quarter and a third of Valero’s ethanol blending obligations for 2009. The five ethanol plants at $280 million with a 560 MMgy cumulative production capacity could amount to the oil company paying only 50 cents per installed gallon of production capacity.

The RFS, RINs and Ethanol Industry Consolidation
There are some important things to remember about the RFS before getting into RINs, or the government’s mechanism to keep track of how much renewable fuel is being blended into U.S. fuel supplies for domestic consumption to meet the RFS, and the state of U.S. ethanol production. First, the RFS is a floor, not a ceiling—it’s the minimum volume obligated parties must blend into U.S. gasoline supplies. During spells of weak economics, however, that floor may act as a ceiling. Second, there is a distinction between U.S. installed capacity, actual U.S. production and consumption by obligated parties to satisfy the federal mandate.

Installed capacity will always be greater than or, at best, equal to actual production. As far as the RFS is concerned, consumption by obligated parties to satisfy the mandate includes consumption of domestic product produced, plus net imports of ethanol, or the delta between exports and imports, plus the change in ethanol stocks at the end of a given period. According to data gathered by BBI International’s Staff Writer and Plant List Manager Bryan Sims, 32 U.S. ethanol plants representing 2.02 billion gallons of annual production capacity are currently idled. This phenomenon, coupled with poor ethanol blend margins—meaning the price of ethanol and the price of gasoline are so close that any economical benefit blenders would see by blending the cheaper ethanol have been minimized—along with the 2008 year-end reporting deadline approaching quickly on Feb. 28, 2009, have together caused RIN prices to skyrocket.


Totals from January 2008 to October 2008 Figures in millions of gallons
SOURCE: ENERGY INFORMATION ADMINISTRATION

“The price of RINs is going up because it’s more favorable to the obligated parties to place RINs in order to satisfy their obligations directly as opposed to the RINs they would get through blending,” says Clayton McMartin, president of Clean Fuels Clearinghouse and the renewable fuels registry, RINSTAR. In late January, RIN prices hit 16 cents per credit, up from just a couple of cents at the beginning of the year. “There are some people who are coming to the game late, and are just now starting to understand what their obligations are under the regulations,” McMartin continues. “Consequently, they’re out there scrambling trying to find RINs, but there is less ethanol being put into the marketplace right now so, as a result, the RINs that are out there are fetching a higher price.” Some of the latecomers buying up RINs in January and February 2009 are doing so to apply them to their 2008 obligations. But obligated parties can also carry a deficit forward for one year without penalty. With 32 ethanol plants idled, and some that are producing under capacity, stocks or inventories are lower. Until inventories are back up, McMartin doesn’t see RIN prices dropping.

But with 10.5 billion gallons of installed production capacity still in operation (likely producing well under nameplate capacity), and with 2.02 billion gallons of installed production capacity idled, without even considering capacity under construction there is fear that the industry is overbuilt versus the mandate. McMartin, with years of experience in the oil business, says consolidation is coming to the ethanol industry. “The first 14 years of my career—and I’ve been at this for 20 some years—was spent in the refining industry, and when I started, the oil refining industry had twice as many refineries as it has today,” he says. “And today those refineries produce more product than what was produced by twice as many refineries years ago. The ethanol industry has now entered into a period when consolidation is coming—it’s overbuilt.” From the perspective of the obligated parties that must blend ethanol or buy RINs, an overbuilt ethanol industry is desirable because ethanol and RIN prices would remain low. For ethanol producers, however, consolidation would mean stronger ethanol prices and a healthier industry long term.

“When you’re in a consolidation period, which is what the ethanol industry is now in, you’ve got hardware on the ground and ultimately it will be utilized, but it won’t be used by the same people who are on the title today,” McMartin says. “They’re going to recapitalize and we’re already seeing some of that.” He says the phenomenon of major oil companies purchasing distressed renewable fuel assets is inevitable. “This is classic consolidation and it will change the complexion of the renewable fuel industry forever,” he tells EPM. “Refiners—and especially Valero—have been in this mode for the past 25 years. Check out the history of Valero—they are the poster child of mergers, acquisitions and consolidation. They are in the energy business. And when you can buy assets for 10 cents on the dollar, it just makes sense.”

Finagling RINs: Not Just an Accounting Function
The quickest way to improve blend economics would be to raise the cost of crude oil, but hoping for higher crude oil prices seems counterintuitive. “Isn’t the objective of the RFS for us to replace crude oil in the United States with renewable fuels?” McMartin poses. “That’s happening today but it’s not being reported.” He says two major factors are driving down the cost of crude oil. “One is we’re approaching having renewables constitute 10 percent of our motor fuels use,” he says. “And the other, of course, is the downturn in the economy; but the downturn in the economy just accelerated what was intended to happen from the RFS.” Displacing petroleum means less of a demand for crude oil, so how is more crude oil put into the marketplace? By lowering the price. “So oil is going to go down, and it will continue to go down so long as renewable fuels use goes up,” he says. “If you’re a renewable fuel producer you do one of two things. You learn to compete at a lower margin—and like I said, the ethanol industry is going through a consolidation period now—or you somehow figure out how to monetize the asset that you’re generating. And that asset that you as an ethanol producer are generating is the renewable fuel credit known as a RIN. Most producers just haven’t recognized that.”

The RIN-Master as McMartin is sometimes referred to, says he is seeing an active market for RINs forming right now. “I’m talking about RINs with fuel and RINs without fuel,” he says. “We’re starting to see premiums placed in the marketplace on fuel with RINs versus fuel without RINs.”

For each gallon of ethanol produced domestically or imported into the United States, a RIN is generated. “EPA wanted to ensure the RIN moved through the supply chain and then, when it got to the end just at the point before the consumer took it and put it in for consumption, the RIN becomes a tradable credit known as a separated RIN,” he says. Assigned RINs are different in that they follow the fuel all the way from the point of production through the supply chain to consumption; for assigned RINs, the credit is not moved independently from the fuel.

“What’s not very well understood is that fuel can move without RINs, so a gallon of ethanol can move with zero RINs and up to 2.5 RINs,” he says. “So if I have a customer who wants to take two RINs and is willing to pay me more for them than the customer who I end up selling zero RINs to, I keep my RINs moving to the individual in the marketplace who’s willing to pay me more for them. That’s what producers should give real serious consideration to doing—but they don’t. Because they move them one for one, they produce them and they move them.”

The general manager for Commonwealth Agri-Energy in Hopkinsville, Ky., Mick Henderson, tells EPM, “We feel that RINs are always bought with the ethanol,” he says. “Even the smallest jobbers have figured out the value of RINs. If they did consider the idea [of moving ethanol with or without RINs], they would undoubtedly bid the ethanol down to a price that would negate the sales value separate anyway. Therefore we don’t see any positive impact for our business, RINs or without.” McMartin says a lot of ethanol plants look at RINs this way, a point of view he says is shortsighted. “You can lead a horse to water but you can’t make it drink,” he says. “If an ethanol producer is going to take control of their product in the marketplace, then this is where they would do it.”

The ability to move from zero to 2.5 RINs per gallon of ethanol gives producers latitude in commercial consideration, which EPA intended all along. “As long as the RIN moves through the system, EPA doesn’t care how it goes,” McMartin says. “They want it to go where economics drive it.”

Valero’s director of regulatory compliance, John Braeutigam, tells EPM that, while he can’t talk about the VeraSun deal or Valero’s business strategy, he says that he doesn’t view the RFS or RINs as necessary evils. “We’re just following requirements set out in regulations,” Braeutigam says. EPM asked him how a refinery would maximize its ownership of ethanol production facilities. “If a company is just an ethanol producer, then there are limited circumstances where they can sell ethanol without RINs,” he says. “Refiners or importers can separate RINs from fuel, and rack blenders can also separate. If an oil refiner had more ethanol plants than they needed and generated more RINs than they needed as an obligated refiner, they would have to sell the rest.”

McMartin speculates as to how Valero might best utilize in-house ethanol production. “It depends on a lot of things, such as how it handles the entity—will it be part of Valero or a separate wholly owned company,” he says. “Also it depends on other ethanol supplied to Valero, since there are limitations under the regulations as to what an obligated party can do with its own production. In the end though, Valero will maximize the assets within the confines of the regulations. You can bet your last dollar that Valero will have ethanol for sale both with and without RINs.”

With 32 ethanol plants idled and some producing under capacity, McMartin says ethanol stocks are being reduced and, until inventories are replenished, he doesn’t expect RIN prices to let up.

Ron Kotrba is an Ethanol Producer Magazine senior writer. Reach him at rkotrba@bbiinternational.com or (701) 738-4942.

Tuesday, March 3, 2009

US Ethanol Industry Eyes Valero's Bid for VeraSun

February 24, 2009

US Ethanol Industry Eyes Valero's Bid for VeraSun

by Jennifer Kho, Contributor
California, United States [RenewableEnergyWorld.com]

Just over a year ago, ethanol manufacturer VeraSun Energy Corp. was one of biofuels' fastest-rising stars. The Sioux Falls, South Dakota-based company had signed partnerships with General Motors Corp. and Enterprise Rent-A-Car Co., was rapidly expanding its production capacity and had announced mergers with ASAlliances Biofuels and US BioEnergy Corp. that would make it one of the largest ethanol companies in the country.

"I think oil companies are definitely going to be players in alternative energy. They bring a lot to the table — money, global reach and, most importantly, distribution."

-- Michael Butler, CEO, Cascadia Capital

Now, the company has become a poster child for the industry's troubles. VeraSun locked in high prices for corn under hedging agreements that put the company at a disadvantage when corn prices fell, and also — like many other ethanol companies — found its margins squeezed by lower ethanol prices. Unable to scrape together enough capital to pay its debts, the company considered, then abandoned, the idea of a secondary public offering in an weakening economic climate.

Finally, in October, VeraSun filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy. The filing is part of a series of ethanol bankruptcies, including Panda Ethanol, Renew Energy, Gateway Ethanol, Greater Ohio Ethanol, Northeast Biofuels, Cascade Grain and many more. Earlier this month, Archer Daniel Midlands told analysts that nearly 21 percent of U.S. ethanol production capacity had been shut down. And biodiesel companies haven't fared much better.

But while VeraSun clearly isn't the first biofuel company to file for bankruptcy in these tough times, the company is the largest publicly traded ethanol producer in the United States. It has about 1.64 billion gallons of annual production capacity and uses about 5 percent of the country's annual corn production, according to court documents. That makes its bankruptcy potentially the most influential so far, and corn farmers and biofuel companies alike are watching the proceedings closely to glean hints about the future of the market.

So far, the company has managed to win US $196.6 million from its existing investors, and also — to the detriment of some of its corn suppliers — to get out of a number of its corn contracts. The rejection of those contracts is costing farmers millions, and that has generated plenty of agricultural complaints and concerns. But it's the forced sale of VeraSun's ethanol refineries that has captured the attention of many biofuel industry watchers.

The bankruptcy court is requiring VeraSun to sell off many of its assets in order to pay its debts, and the company is collecting bids until March 13, with an auction set for later that same month. The pricing on those projects could have "a dramatic impact" on the sector, said Scott Brown, CEO of renewable-energy investment firm New Energy Capital, at the Clean-Tech Investor Summit in California last month. A real markdown could create more declines and "fire sales" in the market, he said then.

If that's the case, the latest bid — from oil company Valero Energy Corp. — could foreshadow the realization of some of those fears. Under the agreement, Valero would buy five refineries, with the capacity to produce a total of 560 million gallons per year, as well as a development site in Reynolds, Indiana, which had had six months' worth of construction toward a 110-million-gallon ethanol plant before construction was suspended in 2007, for a total of $280 million. The bid represents about 25 percent of the estimated cost of building the plants from scratch, said Bill Day, Valero's director of media relations.

Not everyone thinks the price spells bad news, however. Rick Kment, a biofuels analyst with research firm DTN Research, said the sale price is not really a fair indicator of biofuel plants' value, adding that it's tantamount to trying to assess housing values based on a single foreclosure. "Nobody really knows the market value for these plants, and it's uncertain how it ties into the industry," he said.

With few such factories for sale and few potential buyers eyeing the market, it's very difficult to determine whether the bid represents a real market price or an aberration, he said. Kment guessed that the final price will be "a lot less" than the market value. "It might indicate prices short-term, but...I don't see a lot of plants going in and readjusting their value based on these sale prices. I have not seen much of anything as far as other sales of such plants or of fire sales yet."

At the same time, he said, many industry insiders are waiting to see how VeraSun fares for an indication of how the industry will look in the next six months. "Some others are looking to see what kind of options they have, if they are in serious financial trouble, based on how VeraSun comes out of bankruptcy," he said. "A lot of the other ethanol companies are private, so it's hard to see how they're doing because there's very little transparency in their finances and debt structure, and in their buying activities. There are a lot of questions out there, and many are still taking a wait-and-see approach."

All together, at the time of its bankruptcy filing, VeraSun had 16 refineries — 14 of them in operation — and also owned the partly developed Reynolds, Indiana, site. Aside from Valero, VeraSun in November said it had received a nonbinding indication of interest in buying "substantially all of its assets" from an unnamed suitor, which many have speculated is likely to be ethanol company Poet. The company, the No. 1 ethanol producer in the country, had said it was "in serious negotiations" with an undisclosed producer in South Dakota.

VeraSun also kept the price offered in the mystery bid a secret. "It remains to be seen whether other companies will make a bid for these assets, which would give us a clearer idea of what the valuation is," Day said. "To us, this was a fair valuation for these assets, but we will have to see if the bankruptcy court agrees."

Some industry insiders say the fact that an oil company wants to buy into ethanol could be a good sign for the industry, although it also could indicate the coming of some serious competition. Michael Butler, CEO of investment firm Cascadia Capital, said the news is evidence of a trend of some oil companies getting more deeply involved in alternative energy. "I think oil companies are definitely going to be players in alternative energy," he said. "They bring a lot to the table — money, global reach and, most importantly, distribution." Still, he added that he expects oil companies to be more biofuel buyers than investors in the long run. Just last week, RenewableEnergyWorld.com reported on a joint cellulosic ethanol venture between BP and Verenium.

In Valero's case, the company spotted a potentially good deal and decided to bid for the refineries to lock in its own ethanol costs, as oil companies are required to blend ethanol into fuel to meet renewable-fuel and oxygenate mandates, Day said. "As an oil company, we buy up a good amount of ethanol," he said. "We believe ethanol is here to stay as part of our fuel mix — we don't believe the renewable fuel standard will go anywhere but up — and we thought it was a good time to make a bid for those plants."

The company often tries to buy underinvested or distressed assets at a good price and then to build them up to make them profitable or expand them, he said. Day hinted at the possibility that Valero could expand the plants, saying that the refineries are in good locations that would give Valero the ability to add cellulosic technology, "should it become available." Valero last month invested in cellulosic-ethanol startup ZeaChem Inc. It also has invested in algal-fuel company Solix Biofuels and is developing wind farms through its subsidiary, Sunray Wind.

Day added that it's also too early to say whether Valero plans to enter the biofuel business beyond producing what it uses itself. "Obviously, our main business will remain petroleum refining," he said, adding that the ethanol bid is a "relatively small transaction" for a company of its size. Because ethanol production has little in common with refining oil into gasoline — "it's a different production process, with different equipment and different transportation," Day said — Valero would operate the VeraSun plants as a subsidiary, using the existing workforce, he said.

In any case, analysts say you can expect to see more distressed sales in the coming months. "We're seeing pretty sizeable producers come offline; we're seeing sizeable plants delayed and mothballed," said John Quealy, a managing director at investment bank Canaccord Adams. "It's not surprising that we're seeing some of these distressed bids. Commodities are down and folks that have overcommoditized are looking to just exit."

[Editor's note: to read a commentary on the Valero/VeraSun deal, check out David Blume's REInsider this week, Oil Companies and Ethanol Plants: Slash, Burn and Buy.]

Click here for comments to review comments on the Renewable Energy World.com website.