Monday, June 8, 2009

Ethanol Industry Update - Seeking Alpha


by MARIE DAGHLIAN
A combination of lower oil prices and challenging financial markets continues to spell disaster for U.S. ethanol companies, with another 10 providers of this first-generation biofuel going belly up in the first five months of 2009. Among the latest was Pacific Ethanol (PEIX), which saw its shares swoon 44 percent to 32 cents on May 19 when five of its six ethanol-producing units filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection. The company had gone public in 2005 with shares debuting at $12.95.
Since the bankruptcy filing, Pacific Ethanol’s share price has been inching up, trading at 46 cents a share on June 4. But like many of its competitors, the Sacramento, California-based company, which reported sales of $700 million in 2008, has been struggling with a shortage of cash, high corn prices, and lower ethanol prices. At the end of October 2008, VeraSun had one of the first companies to go bust, leading to a succession of firms like Pacific Ethanol that have had trouble staying afloat.
Despite government subsidies and clean-fuel mandates, first-generation corn ethanol companies have had a bumpy ride. The Energy Independence and Security Act of 2007 paved the way for capital projects to ramp up ethanol production to meet the new mandate. But the initial euphoria evaporated when record-high spikes in energy and corn prices rocked the market.
The ethanol industry’s expansion had been an economic driver in 2008, according to industry research. A study commissioned by the Renewable Fuels Association said the industry spent $22 billion on materials and labor and another $2.5 billion on grain transportation services. The investment increased production capacity 34 percent to reach 12.5 billion gallons of ethanol a year, well above the federally mandated requirement of 10.6 billion gallons in the nation’s gasoline supply in 2009. The study also found the ethanol industry generated $21 billion in federal, state, and local tax revenue.
However, market volatility ended up spelling disaster for companies that had borrowed heavily to increase production capacity. Surging energy and feedstock prices, which reached their peak in June 2008, increased both the demand for ethanol and the cost of production. But as the price of oil plummeted, so did the demand for ethanol and the price it could command. Increased production capacity also depressed ethanol prices. At the same time, the economy took a nosedive, quickly landing many ethanol players in trouble. As capital dried up, plants were idled, production projects stalled, and many producers became unable to make payments on their huge debt loads. Production in 2008 ended up falling slightly short of the 9-billion gallon mandate.
Among some of this year’s other casualties, Aventine Renewable Energy Holdings [AVRNQ.PK] was de-listed from the New York Stock Exchange in March and filed a voluntary Chapter 11 petition two weeks later in April, saying it had had nearly $800 million of assets and nearly $491 million of debt at the end of 2008. Once a high flyer, the company's stock debuted at $39.27 in July of 2006. It has been trading around 15 cents a share in recent weeks.
“Ethanol demand has also been negatively affected by refiners and blenders using excess renewable identification numbers (RINs) to help meet their renewable fuels standard obligations instead of purchasing actual gallons of ethanol,” Avertine said in the April 8 statement announcing its Chapter 11 bankruptcy filing. The company also blamed operating margins and high gasoline prices as having negatively affected the ethanol industry. As part of Aventine’s bankruptcy filing, the company and certain holders of its 10 percent senior unsecured notes agreed to a first priority secured debtor-in-possession term loan totaling $30 million so the company could continue operating. However, at the end of May, Aventine began publicly soliciting potential investor interest in order to recapitalize or sell its business, setting a deadline of June 17 the for submissions.
Then there is Cambridge, Massachusetts cellulosic ethanol and enzyme developer Verenium (VRNM), an advanced biofuel company that has attracted a lot of investment, including an ongoing partnership with oil giant BP. The company opened a demonstration-scale cellulosic production facility in Jennings, Louisiana in May 2008 and has plans to build a 36-million gallon commercial facility in Florida in collaboration with BP.
In March, Verenium received a going concern qualification as part of its 10-K form filing with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission as result of doubt on behalf of the auditor that the company can continue to move forward under its heavy debt load and may ultimately need to file for bankruptcy. According to the filing, Verenium has had more than $300 million in net losses over the past three years and an accumulated deficit of $622.6 million as of the end of 2008. If the company is not able to raise additional capital, it will also be on the ropes. Although this has not yet happened, it is interesting to note that its shares went public in February 2003 at $103.88 and once traded as high as $149 a share. On June 4th, they were trading at 65 cents a share.
Even though President Barack Obama’s economic stimulus plan is focused on advanced biofuels development, which has not yet been commercialized, he has not forgotten first-generation biofuels producers, offering refinancing options to the industry. At the same time, the Environmental Protection Agency is considering a rule that would raise the amount of ethanol that must be blended into gasoline from 10 percent to 15 percent. Still, many first-generation biofuel producers continue to struggle to survive, trying to catch a break from banks and debt holders who are reluctant to sell valuable property at fire sale prices. At the same time, oil companies, private equity players, and big agribusinesses are hunting for bargains among the troubled companies. Oil refiner Valero (VLO) paid $477 million in March for seven production facilities belonging to bankrupt VeraSun.
Recently, crude oil futures have been moving toward $70 a barrel, and a bullish oil price forecast to $85 a barrel, issued by Goldman Sachs in the past week, has boosted sentiment among energy investors. Observers might assume that should bode well for ethanol producers, but the recent business failures suggest they may be mistaken.
On a brighter note, not all first-generation ethanol producers are suffering. Privately held Poet, the largest U.S. producer of ethanol, has expressed interest in buying new plants, including ones from recently bankrupt companies, which it claims it can turn around, according to Chief executive Jeff Broin who spoke by telephone with attendees at a recent Reuters Global Energy Summit. The company has developed it own technology for distilling ethanol. Poet, which operates 26 plants in seven Midwest states, has managed to remain profitable even during these difficult economic times.

Related Articles

Wednesday, May 20, 2009

Solar Trough Push in Australia

Australia in race for biggest solar plant

By Peter Smith in Sydney

Published: May 18 2009 17:31 | Last updated: May 18 2009 17:31

Australia plans to build one of the world’s largest solar power station networks in partnership with the private sector as part of its commitment to source 20 per cent of its needs from renewable energy by 2020.

Solar collectors harness energy at a power plant in Harper Lake, California
Solar collectors harness energy at a power plant in Harper Lake, California. A network of US solar plants is planned
Kevin Rudd, the prime minister, said the government would invest up to A$1.4bn ($1bn, €775m, £700m) in solar energy out of the A$4.7bn Canberra has promised to spend on clean energy initiatives over the next decade.

“We don’t want to be clean energy followers worldwide, we want to be clean energy leaders worldwide,” Mr Rudd said. He disclosed that the network would be three times the size of the current largest solar power plant in California.

Australia’s plans mean it will join a global race to construct the world’s biggest solar plant. Earlier this year Southern California Edison, the US utility, signed up with a solar energy company to build a network of plants that would produce 1.3GW of energy, more than Australia envisages but which may take longer to finish.

Proposals for big solar facilities are also being considered in regions such as the Middle East and north Africa, although these are at an early stage.

Australia is one of the world’s leading coal exporters and the country derives 85 per cent of its power from burning the fuel. It has struggled to develop a domestic solar power industry, with a number of infant solar energy technologies moving to more attractive markets such as California.

Canberra said this month that it would delay the introduction of its proposed emissions trading scheme (ETS) by a year, until mid-2011. It was bowing to industry calls for more time to prepare for the scheme as the country’s economy sinks into recession.

At the same time, Canberra raised the upper limit of its carbon reduction target from 15 per cent to 25 per cent by 2020 and promised more industry support.

Climate change was a central campaign theme for Mr Rudd when he won the 2007 election. The rethink over the ETS was a significant turnround for the prime minister, who had only a month earlier said a delay would be irresponsible.

The solar power network, which is not expected to be operational before 2015, aims to produce up to 1,000MW of energy, which compares with Australia’s current energy capacity of 45,000MW.

John Connor, head of the Climate Institute, an independent research group in Sydney, said Canberra’s plan to source 20 per cent of the country’s needs from renewable energy would drive an estimated A$20bn of private sector investment.

“Australia and other countries can’t rely on a silver bullet, and what the government is doing is to help develop a mixed portfolio of clean energy options, which includes wind, geothermal, solar and carbon capture and storage,” he said. The mixed portfolio strategy would help develop the most commercially viable options, he added.

Successful private sector tenders for the solar power network are due to be made public in the first half of next year.

Additional reporting by Fiona Harvey in London

Monday, May 18, 2009

New Energy Finance Summit Clips

Summit 2009 Results

New Energy Finance is proud to present highlights and interviews with 18 of our thought leaders and participants at the recent New Energy Finance Summit, held in London in March 2009.

These interviews provide a very broad selection of perspectives on the current state of the clean energy markets, ranging from policy issues (Nobuo Tanaka, Executive Director, IEA or Jos Delbeke, Deputy Director-General for the Environment, European Commission) to industry (Shai Agassi, Founder and CEO, Better Place or Ricardo Castello Branco, Chief Industrial Officer, Petrobras Biocombustivel) to finance (Paul Deninger, Vice Chairman, Jefferies or Dr. Paul Kloppenborg, CEO, Global Cleantech Capital), to research and NGO's (Henrik Bindslev, Director, Risoe, TUD or Dr. Doug Parr, Chief Scientist, Greenpeace UK).

The full programme of the Summit and bios for many of the interviewees can be found at www.newenergyfinancesummit.com.











Wind Stimulus - Update

March 30, 2009

Wobbly wind sector sets sights on stimulus

SAN FRANCISCO -- Wind power developers have long relied on complex tax-equity financing to bring most of their projects to market, but that system, once hailed as innovative, has collapsed over the last year, leaving the wind sector flailing for the cash it needs to make generation projects a reality.

This is how it worked: Large financial institutions like AIG, Wachovia, J.P. Morgan, Wells Fargo, Lehman Brothers and others would buy federal tax benefits from renewable energy startups that did not have enough taxable income to use the credits on their own.

In other words, big financial firms traded financing to offset tax liability. So-called tax-equity investors would bankroll a solar or wind project in exchange for a tax shelter, which was effectively pinned to profits. The system worked as long as Congress renewed the federal investment and production tax credits that granted developers a range of incentives, and it was widely viewed as a essential avenue within the renewable energy development community.

No more. The system, like other schemes crafted by insiders, has crumbled as AIG, Lehman and others have collapsed. The big boys no longer have cash to bankroll projects or the means to pull the profits to get credits, so the tax-equity space has turned into a financial dead zone.

According to figures from Hudson Clean Energy Partners, about 25 of the largest financial firms were active in tax equity for alternative energy in 2007. But at least 16 of them left the field last year (Greenwire, March 20).

That means an industry that had consolidated behind a handful of major players was left vulnerable to their demise. Wind in particular had banked on tax equity, financing 95 percent of its projects through this system in 2007 and following the same track in 2008 until the crash, according to numbers from J.P. Morgan.

So what now? Experts at a cleantech conference last week offered a simple fix: Figure out how to tap the American Reinvestment and Recovery Act, the economic stimulus law.

Adding finance options

Like their solar counterparts, wind companies sense opportunity in a stimulus provision that provides cash grants in lieu of tax credits for renewable energy. The program has solar companies breathing a sigh of relief, a feeling that appears to have spread to wind developers (Greenwire, March 26).

Under the previous investment tax credit, renewable energy developers could apply a 30 percent credit only to profits as a deduction. But the stimulus, for a period of two years, has made it possible to get back the 30 percent as cash, under a grant program to be administered by the Treasury Department.

Wind power is now eligible for the grant program, the plans for which are still being finalized by Treasury's understaffed tax department. Once the program gets going, one analyst said, the system should thaw frozen credit markets over the next few months -- a little bit at a time.

"It adds a number of options for how to finance a project," said Tyler Tringas, a wind energy analyst at New Energy Finance. "It gives [the developers] a new sort of very large decision tree to finance a wind project."

Standing to benefit, Tringas explained, are smaller projects that were often ignored by large tax-equity investors who were inclined to back bigger installations. Before the meltdown, a small community developer "would be very hard pressed to get an elite group of tax-equity investors," he said.

"You're going to be able to access a much broader base of capital at a lower rate," Tringas said. "This is going to be pretty good for a lot of those marginal projects."

And the policy may have come along just in time. Warren Byrne, founder and CEO of Foresight Wind Energy, and Tom Carbone, CEO of Nordic Windpower, both said the previous system had set up a top-heavy dynamic that may ultimately have hurt the fledgling sector.

"You could count on two hands the companies responsible for financing," Carbone said. "That was a dangerous landscape to have."

Temporary fix?

But others took issue with this maze of tax incentives, so-called partnership swaps and cash grants.

To Yaron Brook, president and executive director of the Ayn Rand Institute, the stimulus is the latest example of government meddling in free markets to subsidize uncompetitive energy sources.

Brook said the government, in setting up the grants, would distort energy markets by favoring wind, solar and other renewable sources. He compared the policy shift under the Obama administration to lawmakers' subsidizing of mortgages, which led to "enormous unintended consequences."

"We should learn from the financial crisis," Brook said. "Using tax policy to get us all into a home was probably not a good idea."

The same could be said of renewable energy, in Brook's view, because the tax policies could divert public dollars away from scalable power plants that do not rely on intermittent energy. "It is going to be disruptive, and it is going to ultimately be destructive -- particularly to entrepreneurs," he said.

Tringas countered that he regards the stimulus as a temporary solution until Congress passes a national renewable portfolio standard, which would send much simpler signals to the market, or a cap-and-trade system to regulate carbon emissions from power plants. He added that he does not believe in government meddling, but he does think lawmakers need to account somehow for the cost of carbon.

"This is enough to keep the wind industry moving forward," Tringas said of the stimulus. "It's enough to prevent the catastrophic collapse that might have happened."

He added, "There was a big problem with the primary source of capital essentially evaporating."

That is just fine for Brook, who said he doubts the science behind climate change and views carbon policy as a giant waste of money.

"I don't believe there's an externality cost to CO2," he told Tringas.

'Dead as hell'

So how badly is the sector hurting? Oil tycoon turned wind speculator T. Boone Pickens recently described the wind market as "dead as hell" to the Wall Street Journal. Richard Saunders, director of project development at GreenHunter Renewable Power, said Pickens was not far off.

Saunders estimates that in 2009, about 4,000 megawatts in new wind capacity will come online. That would be down significantly from the 8,400 MW built last year. And much of the new capacity is "really just things that are carrying over" from permits already issued in 2008.

"They've slowed down their activities tremendously," Saunders said. "They can't get the money."

While Saunders is optimistic that activity will pick up by the end of the year, Geoff Sharples, principal of renewable energy at Google Inc., is not so sure.

"The stimulus is intended to make 2009 not a terrible year," Sharples told attendees at the cleantech conference. "But it's pretty hard to tell how many banks are looking at this and thinking, 'How are we going to come in and make this play?'"

Gregory Jenner, a former tax specialist at Treasury and a partner at Stoel Rives LLP, said Treasury staff members are writing rules for the cash grant program as fast as they can. Jenner said he has talked to staff and expects "something coming out of Treasury very very quickly."

"The bad news is they've never done anything like this before," Jenner added, in a note of warning. "They're trying to figure out how it works."

Copyright 2009 E&E Publishing. All Rights Reserved.

For more news on energy and the environment, visit www.greenwire.com.

Monday, April 20, 2009

Nevada Solar One - Clearinghouse



This is a compilation of links and videos describing Nevada Solar One:


First is Acciona's advertisement announcing the opening of Nevada Solar One in 2007. Click here.


Click here for the Wikipedia Article


The Energy Blog's Nevada Solar One Photos, Write-Up, and Discussion


Click here or read below to review details the financing structure for Nevada Solar One

Structured Leveraged Concentrating Solar Power?

On August first, Acciona Energy closed financing on Nevada Solar One, in the first leveraged lease structured financing in the United States.

This begs two questions:

  1. What in the world is a leveraged lease structured financing?
  2. Why do we care?

What in the World?

An in-depth analysis of the economics of leverage leasing for all three parties involved is available here. Structured financing is a generic term for any form of financing more complex than a loan or a rental. For those of you who need to remain awake, here's the short version: a leveraged lease is a way of obtaining financing that allows the three parties (lenders, equity investors, and lessee) involved to parcel out the risks, tax benefits, and income streams in a way that suits each of their needs.

Why We Care

While using structured finance can lead to substantial financial benefits for the parties involved, the deal can only be done if the lenders believe that the cash flows from the underlying asset, in this case Nevada Solar One, a Concentrating Solar Power (CSP) plant, are sufficiently reliable that they are willing to loan money in exchange for a share of those cash flows.

In other words, the lenders believe that Acciona (ACXIF.PK) will be able to operate the CSP plant with sufficient reliability to earn enough money to eventually pay off the $266 million they put up for the deal. The equity investors believe that the CSP plant will retain some value at the end of the lease, so they will not be left holding the bag.

The completing of a leveraged lease is implicit proof that all the financial institutions involved have a degree of confidence in CSP technology, which they would not have in a development stage technology. By their actions, lenders Spain-based Banco Santander and BBVA, and Portugal-based CAIXA Geral de Depositos and equity investors JPMorgan Capital Corp., Northern Trust (NTRS) and Wells Fargo (WFC), are all saying, "Concentrating Solar Power is a main-stream technology, and we are confident of its predictable operation for the lifetime of the lease." Just as important, they're putting their money where their mouths are.

When lenders believe in predictable cash flows, they reduce the interest rate they charge to finance a project, just as a mortgage company will charge a lower rate of interest to a married couple with steady jobs than they would to a single man who has never worked in his life (if he could obtain a loan at all.) A lower interest rate translates into a lower discount rate when calculating the Levelized Cost of Energy which a technology can produce.

With financial innovation, a group of Iberian and American financial institutions have reduced the cost of energy which will have to be paid by this plants and future CSP plants in the United States just as surely as any technical innovation would. Everyone who wants clean energy at affordable prices should care.

UPDATE: 9/13: In this article on CSP by Fortune/CNN columnist Marc Gunther, he quotes an executive at CSP developer Ausra, saying "As soon as we can build solar power projects with the same cost of capital as building conventional coal or natural gas plants, we'll deliver electricity at the same cost as coal." (emphasis mine.)

DISCLOSURE: Tom Konrad and/or his clients do not have positions in any of the companies mentioned here.

DISCLAIMER: The information and trades provided here are for informational purposes only and are not a solicitation to buy or sell any of these securities. Investing involves substantial risk and you should evaluate your own risk levels before you make any investment. Past results are not an indication of future performance. Please take the time to read the full disclaimer here.

Thursday, April 16, 2009

Sempra Develops Nevada PV Project With First Solar


Sempra is sold on solar
Company expanding Nevada photovoltaic operations

By Onell R. Soto

STAFF WRITER

2:00 a.m. April 16, 2009
Sempra Energy unveiled its new solar facility, which uses thin-film technology, outside of Boulder City, Nev. Several measures are being taken to save money in building the facility. (Tiffany Brown / Las Vegas Sun) -
Jorge Uribe, a construction supervisor for the project, inspected solar panels at the Boulder City facility. (Sempra)

Jorge Uribe, a construction supervisor for the project, inspected solar panels at the Boulder City facility. (Sempra)

Sempra Energy says it has proven that it can inexpensively produce solar power and is greatly expanding its photovoltaic power operations in Nevada to supply customers in the Southwest.

“This project will provide the lowest-cost electricity from solar power ever delivered anywhere in the world,” Michael Allman, chief executive of subsidiary Sempra Generation, said yesterday in announcing a nearly five-fold increase in photovoltaic generation.

The San Diego company said that by the end of next year, it will complete construction of a 48-megawatt photovoltaic plant next to two other plants – a 10-megawatt solar facility and a 480-megawatt natural gas generator – that it owns in the desert.

He said the company wants to be the first to own more than 500 megawatts of solar generation. Engineers believe there is the potential for about 300 megawatts of solar next to the gas-fired Mesquite plant it runs west of Phoenix.

Sempra is also working on generating power using large wind turbines in northern Baja.

The Nevada solar plant, to be called Copper Mountain Solar, will power about 30,000 homes at peak production, the company said.

Allman wouldn't say how much the new solar plant will cost to build or how much the electricity it generates will cost. Electricity in California cost, on average, just under 13 cents a kilowatt-hour last year, the federal Energy Information Administration said.

First Solar of Tempe, Ariz., is expected to begin building the 380-acre plant this year. The 10-megawatt plant, which opened last year, took about six months to build.

Allman said costs are low because land is cheap, its nearly 830,000 solar panels will be installed assembly-line style and it is being built next to existing transmission lines. The plant will use thin-film technology, which produces less power per square inch, but is cheaper to manufacture.

The solar power will still be more expensive than the electricity generated by burning natural gas next door, Sempra said.

The company hasn't decided who will receive the power from the new 48-megawatt plant in Boulder City, Nev., about 40 miles southeast of Las Vegas.

It is talking with utilities in California, Nevada and Arizona, where government mandates are requiring that an ever-larger share of electricity comes from sources that don't burn fossil fuel.

Sempra also owns San Diego Gas & Electric, but the utility is operated independently from Sempra Generation. While SDG&E says it is looking to buy solar power, it's unclear whether it would make a deal with its sister company.

Such deals have to be done at arm's length through a bidding process, said SDG&E spokeswoman Jennifer Ramp.

To meet state mandates, SDG&E is counting on receiving 900 megawatts from Stirling Energy Systems of Phoenix. That company is working on a massive solar plant in Imperial County using solar-powered engines – a technology that has never been proven at large scale.

The utility is well behind meeting a state requirement that it get 20 percent of its power from renewable sources by 2010.

“SDG&E needs to get further down the renewable path,” said Mark Bachman, an analyst with Pacific Crest Securities, in San Francisco.

Pacific Gas & Electric in Northern California has a 20-year deal to purchase power from the 10-megawatt plant in Boulder City, where energy zoning has led to the development and planning of large solar plants.

On Tuesday night, Boulder City approved a lease of 1,000 acres to another company, NextLight, for a 100-megawatt photovoltaic plant.

And a Spanish-owned company, Acciona, operates a 68-megawatt solar plant that generates electricity by heating oil that then boils water to run a steam turbine.

In addition, much larger plants are in the works in California, including a 550-megawatt photovoltaic plant being planned for San Luis Obispo County. PG&E will buy power from that plant, also being built by First Solar.

Onell Soto: (619) 293-1280; onell.soto@uniontrib.com

In the Union-Tribune on Page C1

Thursday, April 9, 2009

Stimulus and the Effects on Renewable Energy Finance

March 20, 2009

Stimulus seen sowing seeds for renewable energy's revival

NEW YORK -- There are signs that the federal stimulus might be pumping a little life into the alternative-energy industry.

Financiers and law firms specializing in renewable energy say they see growing interest in reviving moribund projects and breaking ground on new deals. And while big banks that have braced the industry's backbone are still on the fence, some hedge funds and private equity and venture capital firms are cautiously looking to take advantage of stimulus provisions that temporarily eliminate the need for tax equity financing, which has long been a mainstay for renewable energy projects.

"Whether it's the stimulus package or the return of the banks, there is early evidence of a growing appetite for the types of small- to medium-sized projects that they sponsor," said Tucker Twitmyer, managing partner at the venture capital firm EnerTech Capital.

The stock markets are still no place to raise cash, but if activity from many nontraditional sources of financing lifts the cleantech sector faster, as many experts predict, that may encourage banks to ease their strict lending requirements and again lift renewable energy finance if credit markets start to normalize.

"I'd say it's a little bit like March in your garden," said John Gulliver, a specialist in renewable energy financing at the law firm Pierce Atwood. "There are some shoots of green coming up out of the frozen ground in the snow, but they're not ready to harvest yet."

There is some dispute among insiders as to which sectors are seeing the most benefits. Some are confident that solar energy companies are enjoying a big lift from the stimulus, while others observe signs that wind power is seeing more gains. Most assume that energy efficiency provisions in the law will see home and building weatherization fill up much of the activity, but analysts see opportunities for photovoltaic companies here, too.

But what is clear is that parts of the American Reinvestment and Recovery Act that replace the need for tax credits are giving the industry its biggest boost.

Prior to the financial crash felt in the second half of 2008, most alternative energy projects owed their life to federal investment tax credits and production tax credits that allowed banks backing projects to offset tax liabilities against their investments in wind farms and solar plants.

The structure worked as long as the banks pulled profits, but with most financial institutions expected to post steep losses for 2009, tax credit finance has become all but obsolete.

According to figures from the private equity firm Hudson Clean Energy Partners, about 25 of the largest financial firms were active in tax equity financing for alternatives in 2007, the year most analysts see as the historic height of the cleantech market.

At least 16 of those firms left the field last year, including the permanent departures of Lehman Brothers, Wachovia, Merrill Lynch and American International Group (AIG). For 2009, Hudson Clean Energy counts six bank investors, although 12 could return if the tough financial climate stabilizes.

Congress getting credit

Signs of life in cleantech are mostly due to Congress allowing companies to opt for Treasury grants in lieu of investment tax credits, experts say.

Biomass, geothermal, solar and wind power project developers can now elect to use the investment tax credit to get a federal rebate for the amount of the tax equity money that would have backed their projects.

The advantage, Hudson Clean Energy managing partner Neil Auerbach says, is that the new structure is much simpler and more affordable than the old periodic tax credit schemes favored by Congress in the past. The Treasury grants significantly lower the cost of financing, an important component given the high cost of capital in today's economy.

"Instead of accessing the currency traders in the financial institutional community that charge tremendous transaction costs to access their tax capacity, instead you go to the federal government, specifically the Department of Treasury, and you hand in your tax credit and you get 100 cents on the dollar supposedly within 60 days of a satisfactory application," Auerbach explained in a conference call hosted by the American Council on Renewable Energy (ACORE) on Wednesday.

Aside from the tax credit fix, new and better federal loan guarantees have considerably reduced the cost and risk of financing projects and are helping to lure jittery investors back into renewable energy.

Analysts expect that some of the $6 billion appropriated for loan guarantees will provide the foundation for at least $60 billion in new lending for clean energy projects over the next two years. The financial community is taking notice.

"I'm not saying they've jumped in, but we've gotten more phone calls, and there seems to be a greater degree of interest on the part of nontraditional equity investors, in which I would include things like hedge funds, private equity money, etc.," said Phillip Spector, an attorney specializing in energy and renewables at Troutman Sanders.

A possible stabilization of the fossil-fuel energy markets could also boost optimism and encourage even more firms to take advantage of the new government carrots.

Crude oil prices are now hovering around $50 a barrel. While the market may still see some price swings, many energy analysts theorize that oil prices have probably found a floor and will either stabilize at the $40 to $50 range or steadily rise over that mark in the coming months.

"There may be a perception that oil has bottomed out, and I think that will help if people get confident that they're not going to be competing in a $20 a barrel oil market but one that's $40 to $50 or $60," Gulliver said. "That changes the economics quite a bit."

Anticipating a renewable mandate

Cleantech watchers are also crediting the stimulus for funding several previously authorized measures to lift renewable energy in the United States, in particular programs managed under the Department of Energy that have existed for years but never received funding when Republicans dominated Washington.

But most DOE projects have yet to take effect as stimulus money gets pumped into the economy in pulses. Analysts say it is too soon to tell what impact those appropriations will have on the now stirring alternative energy and clean technology industries.

Insiders also report that, while signs of fresh activity are promising, investors with the most money to spend on cleantech are holding out for indications that forthcoming energy and transportation bills will provide more solid regulatory support for the industry.

While the stimulus is helping to prime the marketplace, there is much hope and anticipation that the federal government will establish a national renewable portfolio standard, or RPS, a mandate that the country generate a specific proportion of its energy needs from wind, solar, geothermal and other such sources. That, along with rules that place a price on a ton of carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gas emissions, will do far more to stimulate cleantech than the law passed last month.

"Everybody is waiting for the next piece, which is the national RPS," said Peter Fusaro, founder of Global Change Associates and organizer of the upcoming Wall Street Green Trading Summit. "The market is going to track legislation. And we're going to get all that next month, hopefully."

Fusaro also expects the industry to get another big lift should Washington adopt a national utility earnings "decoupling" program along the lines of a successful California initiative. Decoupling eliminates the paradox whereby utilities that promote greater energy efficiency see profits fall as demand for their power decreases, establishing structures that guarantee that energy generators can retain their expected earnings.

Ultimately, banks are key

But experts say the renewable energy industry will only return to its heyday once the major banks final loosen up credit and re-enter the fray.

While an important part of the picture, venture capital and private equity investors have nowhere near the amount of capital needed to fuel the industry on the scale that the new leadership in Washington is hoping.

For the Obama administration to meet its goal of doubling renewable energy generation by 2011, Hudson Clean Energy estimates that about $134 billion in new capital investments will be required by then. To reach a 10 percent penetration of renewables in the nation's energy mix by 2012, as President Obama has proposed, about $217 billion will be needed.

The most important remaining impediment to cleantech investing "is the banks not lending," Fusaro said. "We need the capital markets moving again."

The large-scale wind and solar projects of the sort that moved along before the economic crash can get a lift from nontraditional sources of finance, but they almost all still need heavy debt financing to help see them to completion.

While the renewed interest in renewables is promising, the industry won't experience a real breath of life until the banks relax and open up their tight wallets again.

"It's too early to call it spring with the daffodils and tulips up," finance specialist Gulliver said, "but I think you can see signs of green poking up underneath the earth, so that's good."

Copyright 2009 E&E Publishing. All Rights Reserved.

For more news on energy and the environment, visit www.greenwire.com.

Friday, April 3, 2009

Update on Tax-equity Markets

by Cassandra Sweet Dow Jones Newswires
Wednesday, March 04, 2009
SAN FRANCISCO (Dow Jones)

The financial crisis has opened a void in financing for renewable-energy projects as troubled investment banks have pulled back.

The situation has left developers scrambling for funds and eyeing new ideas to fix the broken system.

Some banks, funds and utilities are expected to step up their investment in renewable-energy projects, which had been dominated by big participants like Bank of America Corp. (BAC), JPMorgan Chase & Co. (JPM) and Morgan Stanley (MS). But money hasn't come fast enough for many developers of wind, solar and other clean-energy projects.

Lending was fluid when the banks had large balance sheets and could make use of a 30% renewable energy investment tax credit. The banks would invest in clean-energy projects in exchange for the developing company's tax credit and a related tax write-off called accelerated depreciation. But as losses have mounted, the big investment banks still standing have cut back on their tax-equity financing.

"There have been no unconventional additions to the tax-equity market," said Nick Allen, an equities analyst at Morgan Stanley (MS) in San Francisco. "No one has stepped in and provided funding yet. We hope something will change."

This has left many renewable-energy companies struggling and prompted market participants to pitch new ideas to the federal government to fix the system, even as the Obama administration promises a flood of money in the hope of kick-starting investment in a sector seen key to rejuvenating the economy and weaning the country off fossil fuels.

Tough Choices For Developers; Fixes Pitched

The strains from the collapse of the tax-equity market are starting to show.

Privately held thin-film solar panel maker OptiSolar this week sold its entire portfolio of planned solar power plants, about 1,850 megawatts, to leading thin-film solar panel maker and developer First Solar Inc. (FSLR) for $400 million in stock.

In a similar move, eSolar last month sold off its pipeline of solar-thermal power plants to independent power producer NRG Energy Inc. (NRG) for a $10 million equity investment and a promise by NRG to develop the plants.

Meanwhile, eSolar competitor Ausra, also privately held, said in late January it was abandoning plans to develop and own large-scale solar plants to focus instead on selling its technology to others.

To spur repairs to the system and jump-start investment, market participants like brokerage Meridian Investments Inc., which pegs the value of the renewable energy tax-credit market at $6.5 billion to $9 billion a year, are pitching proposed fixes to the federal government.

Meridian is shopping a tax-credit financing proposal in Washington that the firm says could attract as much as $3 billion in renewable energy investments from Fortune 500 companies this year.

Under the proposal, an investing company would borrow money directly from the Treasury Department at a 10-year Treasury note rate. The company wouldn't make any payments for the first five years, and would pay off the note in the second five years, when the note would fully amortize, said Jack Casey, the firm's vice chairman in Washington.

"We think this is the best way to do it," said Casey, whose firm has placed about $15 billion in tax-credit equity financing over the last 28 years. "It's no handout, it's just timing and credit."

Meridian's investor-note financing proposal would boost the yield on such transactions from about 8% currently, to as much as 14%, Casey said, adding several large companies, including utilities and non-energy firms, have expressed interest in the plan. The firm hopes to speak with Treasury Secretary Timothy Geithner this month about the proposal, which would include tax credits for investments in low-income housing and historical restoration projects.

Opportunities Emerging?

The pullback by the big investment banking houses also may be creating opportunities for regional banks to expand their role in renewable-energy investment. Banks with experience in affordable-housing tax credits and new-markets tax credits for developing retail and other commercial operations in low-income areas may be especially well placed.

"There's a lot of talk about who's going to fill the void," said Russ Landon, managing director of investment banking at Canaccord Adams in Boston, which helps put financing deals together and provides research on public companies. "I think you'll see some of the regional (banks) come in and do it if they have money."

Minneapolis-based U.S. Bancorp (USB) has invested in about a dozen renewable energy projects over the last year by providing tax-equity financing, and the company said it will likely expand its investing in renewables, drawn in part by government incentives in the economic-stimulus bill passed last month.

"We're interested in growing our presence in that space, from the project finance side and the tax-equity side," said Zack Boyers, chairman and chief executive of U.S. Bancorp's Community Development Corporation in St. Louis, the unit that makes the investments. He added that the bank has received numerous inquiries from renewable-energy developers in recent weeks.

Meanwhile, California's Union Bank just closed on $20 million in project financing for SunEdison, a Beltsville, Md.-based solar-panel installer backed by Goldman Sachs Group Inc. (GS), Allco Finance Group Ltd. and other investors. The bank has invested in about 17 projects over the last five years, with about nine of those deals done in the last six months, said Lance Markowitz, senior vice president at Union Bank.

"Given the impetus from the government, there are a lot of people working on a lot of projects," Markowitz said. "We're hoping to do more."

(Cassandra Sweet covers power, natural gas, renewable energy and carbon markets for Dow Jones Newswires.)

Copyright (c) 2009 Dow Jones & Company, Inc.

Monday, March 23, 2009

Production Tax Credit (PTC) Status & History

Production Tax Credit for Renewable Energy

In one of the last measures taken by the 110th Congress, critical tax incentives for promoting the development of renewable energy and energy efficiency were extended. The tax incentives were set to expire on December 31, 2008, but due to the efforts of a very diverse coalition that included UCS, they were extended as part of the Emergency Economic Stabilization Act of 2008 that President Bush signed on October 3, 2008.

Companies that generate wind, geothermal, and “closed-loop” bioenergy (which is powered by dedicated energy crops) are eligible for the production tax credit (PTC), which provides a 1.9-cent per kilowatt-hour (kWh) benefit for the first ten years of a renewable energy facility's operation. Other technologies, such as "open-loop" biomass, incremental hydropower, small irrigation systems, landfill gas, and municipal solid waste (MSW), receive a lesser value tax credit.

The PTC for wind, which as the largest producer of renewable energy has the greatest impact on the budget, was extended for one year, until the end of 2009.

The PTC for incremental hydro, geothermal, and bioenergy was extended for two years, until the end of 2010. Also included in the two-year extension of the PTC are hydropower generated with irrigation water, capacity expansion at existing plants, and with generators added to existing dams. The bill also creates a new PTC for electricity produced by wave and tidal energy.

Businesses and individuals who buy solar energy systems are eligible to receive the solar energy investment tax credit. For residential purchasers, the solar ITC is capped at 30% of the cost of their system; a $2,000 cap on the ITC for residential owners was lifted.

In addition, the bill extended incentives for energy efficiency. Tax deductions for energy-efficient commercial buildings are extended through 2013. Tax deductions for energy-efficient home improvements are re-instated, with a new $300 tax credit for energy-efficient biomass fuel stoves. Tax credits for builders of new energy-efficient homes are extended through 2009 and increases and extends tax credits for manufacturers of energy-efficient appliances through 2010.

This marks just the third time that the PTC was extended by Congress before it had been allowed to expire. At the end of the 109th Congress, the PTC and ITC were extended to the end of 2008 as part of the Tax Relief and Health Care Act of 2006 (H.R. 6408). Previously, in August 2005, a two-year extension of the PTC was included in a large package of tax incentives in the Energy Policy Act of 2005 (H.R. 6); the solar ITC was created in 2005 as part of HR 6. The PTC was set to expire at the end of 2005, and its extension was one of the few bright spots for renewable energy in this energy bill.

From 1999 until 2004, the PTC had expired on three separate occasions. Originally enacted as part of the Energy Policy Act of 1992, the PTC—then targeted to support just wind and certain bioenergy resources—was first allowed to sunset on June 30, 1999. In December of 1999, again due to the efforts of UCS and other organizations, the credit was extended until December 31, 2001. The PTC expired at the end of 2001, and it was not until March 2002 that the credit was extended for another two years. Congress allowed the PTC to expire for the third time at the end of 2003. From late 2003 through most of 2004 attempts to extend and expand the PTC were held hostage to the fossil-fuel dominated comprehensive energy bill that ultimately failed to pass during the 108th Congress. In early October 2004, a one-year extension (retroactive back to January 1, 2004) of the PTC was included in a larger package of 'high priority' tax incentives for businesses signed by President George Bush. A second bill—extending the PTC through 2005 and expanding the list of eligible renewable energy technologies—was enacted just a few weeks later.

Combined with a growing number of states that have adopted renewable electricity standards, the PTC has been a major driver of wind power development over the past six years. Unfortunately, the "on-again/off-again" status that has historically been associated with the PTC contributes to a boom-bust cycle of development that plagues the wind industry (see Figure below). The cycle begins with the wind industry experiencing strong growth in development around the country during the years leading up to the PTC's expiration. Lapses in the PTC then cause a dramatic slow down in the implementation of planned wind projects. When the PTC is restored, the wind power industry takes time to regain its footing, and then experiences strong growth until the tax credits expire. And so on.

The last lapse in the PTC—at the end of 2003—came on the heels of a strong year in U.S. wind energy capacity growth. In 2003, the wind power industry added 1,687 megawatts (MW) of capacity—a 36 percent annual increase. With no PTC in place for most of 2004, U.S. wind development decreased dramatically to less than 400 MW—a five-year low. With the PTC re-instated, 2005 marked the best year ever for U.S. wind energy development with 2,431 MW of capacity installed—a 43 percent increase over the previous record year established in 2001. With the PTC firmly in place, 2006 was another near record year in the U.S. wind industry. Wind power capacity grew by 2,454 MW—a 27 percent increase. The American Wind Energy Association tallied 5,244 MW of capacity installed in 2007 and expects 2008 to be another record year.

However, without changes to the PTC and ITC, renewable energy deployment is expected to slow considerably in 2009. The economic downturn of late 2008 has left many renewable energy developers with dwindling profits. As their profits slump, renewable developers have less “appetite” for tax credits, As a result, the declining value of the PTC and ITC is expected to slow investments in renewable energy facilities. In the next congress, UCS, our allies and renewable energy developers will be working to revise the PTC and ITC to make them refundable. Refundable credits will ensure that renewable energy development will continue even when the economy slows—the very time sustained growth in renewable energy is needed most to create jobs and income.

Short term extensions of the PTC will allow the wind industry to continue building on previous years' momentum, but it is insufficient for sustaining the long-term growth of renewable energy. The planning and permitting process for new wind facilities can take up to two years or longer to complete. As a result, many renewable energy developers that depend on the PTC to improve a facility's cost effectiveness may hesitate to start a new project due to the uncertainty that the credit will still be available to them when the project is completed.

UCS is continuing to work with our coalition partners to extend and revise tax incentives for renewable energy that help boost development of clean renewable electricity, not polluting energy sources.

Last Revised: 11/14/08

Wednesday, March 18, 2009

Report from the Renewable Energy World Conference

March 16, 2009

Optimism Abounds Throughout Renewable Energy Industry

Las Vegas, United States [RenewableEnergyWorld.com]

Last week the editors at RenewableEnergyWorld.com and Renewable Energy World magazine traveled to Las Vegas to attend the 6th annual Renewable Energy World North America (REWNA) Conference and Expo. With almost twice the attendance of last year's event and more than double the exhibitors, the show's exponential growth in spite of a dismal economy is a testament to the strength of the renewable energy industry.

The problems for companies created by the recession are apparent. But the enthusiasm and recognition of the incredible prospects for renewables dominated the discussion.

We captured video interviews with dozens of experts in the renewable energy field on topics including energy storage and the smart grid, the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act, Hydropower, CPV, algae and much, much more. Taken together, the videos show an upbeat, enthusiastic renewable energy industry despite all of the economic turmoil surrounding it — truly the glimmer of hope that is needed today.

The editors started the week with a tour of the El Dorado thin-film solar facility (see lead photo). The 10-MW project is the largest thin-film installation in North America, covering 88 acres with 167,400 First Solar Cadmium Telluride panels.

When the conference started, editors roamed the conference floor gathering a range of video interviews with analysts and business executives on new technologies and policy developments.

Interested in tracking what's happening in the broader clean tech space? Check out our conversation with RenewableEnergyWorld.com contributing writer Clint Wilder on Clean Edge's Clean Energy Trends 2009 Report, which includes the 5 key technologies to watch in clean tech as well as Wilder's comments on the state of the industry.

One of the most popular energies in the space is algae. While there weren't many algae companies at the conference, there was still a lot of talk about what role this prolific organism will play in the fuel market. Editor Jennifer Runyon spoke with Mark Braly about what experts are saying about this burgeoning industry.

Of course, finance is a big issue in the renewable energy space. Braly and Runyon also sat down to talk about the lack of project finance and what types of projects are actually getting the capital to move forward. Braly talked about utility PV projects as well, which are rapidly gaining ground. According to the Solar Electric Power Association, there are now 2,200 MW of projects being pushed forward by 10 utilities around the U.S. This made utility involvement in the solar industry a hot topic at the conference.

While interest in traditional PV is still growing, new solar technologies are sprouting up everywhere, increasing the amount of attention the industry is getting. Stephen Lacey spoke with one of the oldest players in the Concentrating PV space, Amonix, about what the increased competition means for well-established players.

Darren Kimura, CEO of Sopogy, also spoke with Lacey about the company's micro-CSP parabolic trough collectors, which are extending the solar thermal industry to a variety of meet on-site generation needs.

Sopogy is currently working on a major project in Spain — one of many solar projects being developed for the country's very hot solar market. But the 2009 cap on installations will certainly dampen the Spanish industry's growth this year, which may provide more incentive for Spain-based companies to branch out into other markets. Brian Gaylord, a market analyst for the Spanish Trade Commission, talked with Lacey about the growing international presence of Spanish companies.

This trend is certainly being felt here in the U.S. wind industry as companies from Spain and other European countries buy up and develop American wind assets. News Editor Graham Jesmer spoke with the new CEO of the American Wind Energy Association, Denise Bode, about the incredible growth in foreign and U.S. wind businesses, which put around 8,300 MW of capacity online last year.

Wind is a great resource to harvest, but there is also a need to harvest more stable forms of baseload renewables. The answer is geothermal, said Geothermal Energy Association Executive Director Karl Gawell in an interview with Jesmer.

We may see a slowdown in wind and other renewables well into this year, but the recent stimulus package, which sets aside $67 billion for clean energy, energy efficiency and smart-grid technologies may reverse that downward trend. Jesmer caught up with John McKinsey of the law firm Stoel Rives to talk about when the stimulus may have an impact. He also talked with Piper Jaffray's Chris Flannery about the details of the program and the need to create more project finance opportunities for the industry.


All in all, the conference was a great success. The problems for companies created by the recession are apparent. But the enthusiasm and recognition of the incredible prospects for renewables dominated the discussion. We hope you enjoy the interviews. We'll see you next year in Austin, Texas.

Photo Credit: David Wagman